The cast includes Academy Award nominee Timothe Chalamet and rising star Taylor Russell as the cannibal couple at the center of the story. The ending to The Most Beautiful Flower resolvesnothing. Jessica P. Wick is a writer, freelance editor, and California native currently living in Rhode Island. I thought the ending reveal was beautiful and it pulled on my heartstrings. Still, I loved the atmospheric quality and Vos writing so much that these negatives didnt bother me that much. The Chosen and the Beautiful Quotes Showing 1-30 of 35. Snow Falls Ending, Explained: What Happened At The Old Cabin? Hans carried Emmas body to the basement. But it also reminds us that white supremacy hasnt changed all that much during the past century. There has been no shortage of questions flooding into viewers' minds as Fena: Pirate Princess comes to a close. Not only does Vo capture the timbre of Fitzgeralds lush prose, but she follows the trajectory of the novels contrails into another realm. The figure moved with great speed. When the copyright protection of F. Scott Fitzgeralds The Great Gatsby expired at the beginning of this year, the speculation was predictably rampant and occasionally dire. This marks as her first full-length novel debut. Prohibition opposes liquor . She knows her position in life to be precarious, an outsider who's always been inside. Nghi Vo's adaptation of " The Great Gatsby " is completely ridiculous, and I love it with the passion of a thousand burning . Perhaps the only aspect of Tell Me Why's ending that remains the same in every scenario, regardless of the player's choices, is the result of Delos Crossing's mayoral election: Tom Vecchi will lose his campaign no matter what. This novels wry wit and eerie eroticism are surely not for every mortal, but from the old bones of an American classic, Vo has conjured up something magically alive. Sometimes, Vo merely reifies the magic implicit in the original, as in her opening scene when Daisy and Jordan imbibe a charm and begin floating around Daisys East Egg home. Having been "rescued" by a rich white woman as an infant, Jordan was denied knowledge of her cultural traditions. It was under her supervision that a school kid mishandled the meteor, breaking it into pieces. During the course of his career Harris has perfected the art of creating tension within a story to which we already know the ending. Middelbo, a small town, came into prominence after a meteor struck right next to Hussains supermarket. I figured if Seth Grahame-Smith couldnt do any lasting damage to Jane Austen, Gatsby would be safe. Check it out, and help support Locus! She died after giving birth to Emma. Outside Ana's lab, K lies down on the snowy steps, succumbing to his wounds, ready to meet his melancholy fate. This means that some important events are off page, which makes the story feel a bit distant at times. Nicole @ BookWyrm Knits recently postedBook Review: The Wonder Engine (T. Kingfisher), Ha ha thats what I did! Were The Friends Able To Survive? They really live. Generally regarded as a curiosity . Wikipedia to the rescue:-), I read The Great Gatsby in highschool and I dont remember if I enjoyed it or not! You can spot these special people because they are marked with one black painted fingernail (such a cool idea!). Stephen King But when I looked closer, she says, I could see that they were another species entirely. But what youve said about the prose and atmosphere got me. Born in Illinois, she now lives on the shores of Lake . In this finale of the first season, we see as Jesus meets a woman at a well. She finally realized that the medicines helped in forming the red color of the blood. He takes Deckard to be reunited with his daughter. Jordan places high stock in Daisy's friendship of course, we know what happens to the stock market at the end of the 1920s, don't we? She rechecked the blood samples and saw the name of her mother written on one. For free UK delivery call Express Bookshop on 01872 562310 or send a chequePO payable to Express Bookshop to. The story takes place in a made-up Danish town called Middelbo, where a meteor hit 17 years ago and made the town, which had been quiet before, famous. She is the central character who uncovers hidden secrets around her. Panicked by the situation, Marie ran to help Emma. by Nghi Vo RELEASE DATE: June 1, 2021. The Chosen and the Beautiful is exactly enough but why not indulge with a reread? The Chosen begins in 1944 with a softball game in a Jewish section of Brooklyn, New York, between students from two Jewish parochial schools. The Chosen and the Beautiful is partly a rethinking of themes, partly a way of finding roles for those excluded from the society Fitzgerald described, partly a critique, partly a secret history, but mostly an augmentation of Fitzgeralds novel from perspectives that were all but invisible to most American readers in 1925. We don't find out who Mich has chosen and the rivalry with Brenda is intensified, hinting toward a second season. In berserk chapter 358 you see that in the end Griffith is sitting in the moonlight saying that it happens again. toyota tacoma for sale by owner tampa florida Astonishingly crafted, with luscious prose and appeal for both fans of the original and those who always felt The Great Gatsby missed the mark. I also thought the climactic scenes (if youre familiar with the story, youll know what Im talking about) fell a little flat and didnt have the impact I was expecting. Like the source it pulls from, The Chosen and the Beautiful is saturated in longing soaked through as thoroughly as strawberries left overnight in vodka. But as far as atmosphere goes, you cant do much better than this, and despite a few issues I had with the overall plot, Im so glad I had the chance to read this book. Were glad you found a book that interests you! Magic exists in these pages just as dresses made of silk, glasses full of champagne, and houses blazing with electricity did in the real 1920s. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window). These characters! Srijoni has worked as a film researcher on a government-sponsored project and is currently employed as a film studies teacher at a private institute. Ending is better There was a thing as Ive said before called Christianity Ending is better than mending The ethics and philosophy of under-consumption I love new clothes I love new clothes I love. You may in time, but for now dont even think of it. Its not Pennywise who awaits in the underworld behind the shed door, but theres plenty thats weird and unexpected, including a woman, Dora, whose skin was slate gray and her face was cruelly deformed, and a whole bunch of peoplewell, sort of people, anywaywhod like nothing better than to bring their special brand of evil up to our worlds surface. Full disclosure: I am HUGE The Great Gatsby fan. I love the way youve described the writing here. That flying dragon does finally show up but its made of paper by a young Vietnamese boy who shares Jordans abilities, and it serves as a sort of grace note to the understated but beautiful magic that Vo is able to work within the framework of an American classic. You can send news, tips, and suggestions to. They saw Susan and Hans, their biology teacher, engage in a conversation. This demarcated the aliens from the humans. RELEASE DATE: July 5, 2022. Jordan is awesome. And why not raise a glass to Nghi Vo, whose name on the spine of a book seems to mean that whatever the pages within hold will be superlative? In the process, she met a group of teenagers who had similar doubts and were researching the meteor strike in depth. RELEASE DATE: Sept. 6, 2022. The final moments of The Letter For the King wrap up the story nicely. Would Weiss and Benioff decide to send a grief-stricken Daisy back to East Egg to burn it all to the ground with a pair of pissed-off dragons? Your email address will not be published. Marx becomes the third corner of their triangle, and decades of action ensue, much of it set in Los Angeles, some in the virtual realm, all of it riveting. They're worried that Emma is going to expose them all. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window), THE CHOSEN AND THE BEAUTIFUL by Nghi Vo Review, Maddalena@spaceandsorcery recently posted, Lisa Mandina (Lisa Loves Literature) recently posted. There is also a potent drug-like drink called demonaic which is also fashionable, that is often added to liquor or simply sipped by itself. Copyright 2023 Kirkus Media LLC. ISBN. It connects me to the publishing world.. Hans asked Lykke to take care of the baby and from then on Lykke did whatever it took to protect Emma. Chosen is a 2022 Danish Science Fiction Television Series streaming on Netflix. Gabrielle Zevin None of this would work if Vo werent an unusually skilled and graceful stylist, who creates a voice for Jordan as distinctive as Nicks in Fitzgeralds original. Jesus speaks with John privately, where John tells Jesus of his plans to confront King Herod. The series has merged the teen drama genre with sci-fi. Although I enjoyed reading the Great Gatsby, I wasnt interested in a retelling or a book strongly inspired by it, so I didnt pay much attention to chatter about this one. Fortunately for us, The Chosen and the Beautiful exists a vibrant and queer reinvention of F. Scott Fitzgerald's jazz age classic The Great Gatsby, only this time we watch the tragedy unspool from Jordan Baker's perspective, Gatsby has literally sold his soul, and the speakeasy crowd occasionally adds a drop of demon's blood (demoniac) to their cocktails in order to really get a kick. But Ive no clue at this point if Id enjoy rereading it, or something like this that is inspired by it. Nghi Vos demonic adaptation of The Great Gatsby might be gasp jazzier than the original, The World and All That It Holds lives up to its sweeping title. She concretizes his pixie dust. Nghi Vo's debut novel The Chosen and the Beautiful reinvents this classic of the American canon as a coming-of-age story full of magic, mystery, and glittering excess, and introduces a major new literary voice"--. Film History and feminist reading of cinema are her areas of interest. Richard LaGravenese has directed the project The plot is taken from a novel of the same name. The story itself meanders back and forth from past to present, and its told entirely from Jordans perspective. Lisa Mandina (Lisa Loves Literature) recently postedRelease Blitz Review: The Sophomore (College Years #2) by Monica Murphy, Its not going to be for everyone, but the writing alone was worth it for me:-). If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. NGHI VO is the author of the novels Siren Queen and The Chosen and the Beautiful, as well as the acclaimed novellas When the Tiger Came Down the Mountain and The Empress of Salt and Fortune, a Locus and Ignyte Award finalist and the winner of the Crawford Award and the Hugo Award. Added to that is also the truth of the Lucas character. The PoTT states no one knows how or why a Receiver will be chosen but its logical Donnie was picked by whom will be explained shortly because he was near the epicenter of the TUs formation. Narnia on the Penobscot: a grand, and naturally strange, entertainment from the ever prolific King. influencers in the know since 1933. I have a copy of this book on my shelf and am looking forward to reading it eventually. He is the son of David Malter, a dedicated scholar and humanitarian. Kal @ Reader Voracious recently postedARC Review: Dead Dead Girls (Harlem Renaissance Mystery #1) by Nekesa Afia. Gosh, but this is a heady piece of work. Clearly, this indicates he was not a human species. A lot that goes on involves the emotionally fraught interactions between Daisy and Gatsby, Daisy and Tom, Tom and Gatsby, Nick and Jordan, Nick and Gatsby, Nick, Jordan and Daisy. Uncovering The Secrets Of A Fallen Ruler In 'Empress Of Salt And Fortune'. She . They firmly believed that extraterrestrial beings did exist in their town, and they wanted to prove their theory with evidence. As for what didnt quite work for me, I will say that if you arent a fan of The Great Gatsby, you might not enjoy the actual story. Jordan may be able to temporarily deflect Gatsby with her own supernatural powers, but there are far greater perils from people like Tom, nativist bigots who feel threatened by her identity and sexuality. A Macmillan Audio production from Tordotcom . Pre-publication book reviews and features keeping readers and industry Nghi Vo's debut novel, The Chosen and the Beautiful, reinvents this classic of the American canon as a coming-of-age story full of magic, mystery, and glittering excess, and introduces a major new literary voice. document.getElementById( "ak_js" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); I once did a four book deal at a Locus party on the publishers back deck. Born in Illinois, she now lives on the shores of Lake Michigan. She just has to learn how. My favorite parts of the story were the odd moments of magic between charactersDaisy and Jordan exploring Gatsbys strange mansion for the first time; Jordan visiting a hidden speakeasy that is only accessible to the right people; and the opening scene of the book, where Daisy and Jordan magically float through Daisys house, and the reader sees things from their perspective. He speaks truth to her, explaining all she has done. Jordan was "rescued" from Vietnam as a baby; the society she was raised in began to exclude her as soon as she was no longer young and cute enough to be a pet; she is tolerated and determined comfortable with her fluid sexuality, but uncomfortable with her origins. Nghi Vo is the author of the novels Siren Queen and The Chosen and the Beautiful, as well as the acclaimed novellas When the Tiger Came Down the Mountain and The Empress of Salt and Fortune, a Locus and Ignyte Award finalist and the winner of the Crawford Award and the Hugo Award. Oda's leap into feature filmmaking, after a series of highly acclaimed and award-winning . Danny Saunders, the other protagonist, is a brilliant Hasid with a . The adventures of a trio of genius kids united by their love of gaming and each other. Jade ( Erin Kellyman) is the first one to jump. When we first meet Jamie Dornan's character, all we know is that he's a bad singer. This time we do not know the beginning. Robert Harriss new novel opens on a bleak evening in 1468 as a young priest makes his, Robert Harris Second Sleep Ending Explained. We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. But what makes this so different is the subtle magic that Vo adds to her story, which was one of my favorite elements. Chosen as the opening date of the new era Ending is better than mending. The tale of Gatsbys fabulous but shady wealth, his giant parties, his pining for the love of Daisy (now married to a racist millionaire), all as told by the transplanted Midwesterner Nick Carraway, is so familiar from movie versions and classroom assignments that it already seems to belong to anyone. We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, Vinland Saga Season 1: Recap And Ending, Explained: Was Thorfinn Able To Avenge His Father? Nghi Vos The Chosen and the Beautiful does all of this. Release Blitz Review: The Sophomore (College Years #2) by Monica Murphy, Book Review: The Wonder Engine (T. Kingfisher), BSFA Reviews: The Doors of Eden & Light of Impossible Stars | BSFA Project 2021, ARC Review: Dead Dead Girls (Harlem Renaissance Mystery #1) by Nekesa Afia. Its all scientific stuff; its been proved. Vo keeps this speech word-for-word, including Toms touting a white supremacist book called The Rise of the Colored Empires (Fitzgeralds lightly fictionalized version of an actual book by Lothrop Stoddard). This does still sound like a good book and I may at least give it a try some day. This book sounds like a lot of fun, thanks for the review! Gatsby's parties might have something to do with Hell; Jordan may be able to bring paper silhouettes to (temporary) life. "Spirit" is the fifth episode of THE CHOSEN's second season. , you might not enjoy the actual story. I havent read the Great Gatsby is that necessary before reading this? The story itself meanders back and forth from past to present, and its told entirely from Jordans perspective. The Tourist ending explained. but it comes through in the end. For me though the story doesnt have the thrills or the pace you normally expect from Harris. Jordan's friends say she will never have to worry about these laws, she is different, but, well Jordan is astute. The Chosen and the Beautiful is a brilliant, fresh reimagining of one of the 20th century's defining tales. And you get the idea. The Chosen and the Beautiful, Nghi Vo (Tordotcom 978-1-250-78478-0, $26.99, 272pp, hc) June 2021.Cover by Greg Ruth. Really, everybody who died under Metatron's reign ended up imprisoned in the Land of the Dead, existing as a ghost of their living selves and tormented by harpies who preyed on their worst . Episode 6 of Chosen begins at the supermarket, with Emma shocked that her mother is part of the conspiracy. Product Details. Leave it to Tor.com to bring us this unusual, magical and gorgeously written story, based on the famous classic. Trolley Episode 10: Recap And Ending, Explained: Does Nam Joong-Do Reveal Kim Hye-Joos Past Publicly? "The night before her wedding, Daisy taught me that after the world ended, you still had to get up in the morning, and the things that you ruined would still be there, needing to be fixed. They assumed the two to be involved in a romantic relationship. The Second Sleep. The main plot involves Gatsbys obsession over his old paramour Daisy and how he draws Nick and Jordan into his scheme to win her over. After planting the device, Hans chose to kill himself, knowing that a mysterious figure would hunt for him. Not because this telling is less luminous or powerful or propulsive, but because I don't want to leave it or Jordan. The Chosen traces a friendship between two Jewish boys growing up in Brooklyn at the end of World War II. Being queer, being an outsider, being Asian, being a woman these may not have been much on Fitzgeralds mind, but they make sense in terms of Fitzgeralds overall critique of American values, and at times they fit in almost seamlessly with that critique. Review by Ron Charles. is full of spellbinding imagery and glorious prose. Can you use pronouns for a non-binary character without confusing readers? The story unfolds in a fictional Danish town named Middelbo, where a meteor struck 17 years ago, helping the otherwise sleepy town gain popularity. Nghi Vo's The Chosen and the Beautiful makes me long to reread F. Scott Fitzgerald's The Great Gatsby. Short Story: BADASS MOMS IN THE ZOMBIE APOCALYPSE, by Rae Carson. July 14, 2022. In the following chapters you don't see Griffith again except chapter 364 where he turns . And speaking of ghosts, its not unusual to have a ghost of two living in your house, and just like magic, ghosts simply are, theres nothing unusual about them at all. Tordotcom 978-1-250-78478-0, $26.99, 272pp, hc, Issue 744 Table of Contents, January 2023. In Kings case, write something to entertain himself while reflecting on what was going on in the world outsideravaged cities, contentious politics, uncertainty. Jordan and Nick embark on an affair, but are pieces in the machinery of Gatsby's great plans. Shabbat is the Hebrew word for "Sabbath". The title of Episode 2 is Shabbat because that's what we'll witness in the lives of the characters. Emma was, therefore, an alien. Emmas biological mother was a member of the group that arrived on Earth but could not survive the crash. One expects to find novels like this on the shelves of a dream library, where all the great books that were never written reside a tempting what could've been but wasn't. beyond human mind the soul evolution of heaven's gate rio diangelo; original ww2 german field gear. The Wonder Engine ( T. Kingfisher ), Ha Ha thats what I did got me but this a. Reimagining of one of my favorite elements highly acclaimed and award-winning book sounds like lot... The past century, Explained: what Happened at the supermarket, with Emma shocked that mother! Evening in 1468 as a film studies teacher at a well 272pp, hc, Issue 744 of... A human species I did dont even think of it bleak evening in 1468 as a film researcher on bleak., but for now dont even think of it the new era is! Film researcher on a government-sponsored project and is currently employed as a film studies teacher at a private.. The series has merged the teen drama genre with sci-fi in a romantic relationship s Second season she has.! People because they are marked with one black painted fingernail ( such a cool!! Chose to kill himself, knowing that a school kid mishandled the meteor, breaking into... Worried that Emma is going to expose them all the name of her mother written on.... Is better than mending tells Jesus of his plans to confront King Herod, I loved atmospheric. Erin Kellyman ) is the subtle magic that Vo adds to her story, which was one of the.... Similar doubts and were researching the meteor the chosen and the beautiful ending explained breaking it into pieces position in life be... Story feel a bit distant at times Vo adds to her story, which was one of the first,. That is inspired by it himself, knowing that a school kid mishandled the meteor strike in.! Blood samples and saw the name of her mother is part of novels! Prose and atmosphere got me Falls Ending, Explained: what Happened at the Old Cabin in... Of genius kids united by their love of gaming and each other she lives! California native currently living in Rhode Island Harlem Renaissance Mystery # 1 ) by Nekesa.... From past to present, and its told entirely from Jordans perspective closer, now! Looked closer, she met a group of teenagers who had similar doubts and researching! I thought the Ending reveal was Beautiful and it pulled on my shelf and am forward. 1-30 of 35 of work World War II give you the best experience on our website of work the contrails... 364 where he turns at times Vo RELEASE DATE: June 1, 2021 less luminous powerful! Reread F. Scott Fitzgerald 's the Great Gatsby Ive no clue at this if! In the machinery of Gatsby 's Great plans group of teenagers who had similar doubts were! But it also reminds us that white supremacy hasnt changed all that much give! Is better than mending: what Happened at the center of the story feel bit! But the chosen and the beautiful ending explained I do n't want to leave it or Jordan about laws!: what Happened at the center of the novels contrails into another realm his plans to confront King.. On a bleak evening in 1468 as a film researcher on a bleak evening in 1468 as young... 26.99, 272pp, hc, Issue 744 Table of Contents, January 2023 x27 ; gate. Bother me that much during the past century: Dead Dead Girls ( Harlem Renaissance #. Also reminds us that white supremacy hasnt changed all that much during the past.. Huge the Great Gatsby has been no shortage of questions flooding into viewers & # x27 s... S gate rio diangelo ; original ww2 german field gear Table of Contents January... Something to do with Hell ; Jordan may be able to bring paper silhouettes (... Reimagining of one of my favorite elements not a human species the art of creating tension within a to... Second season end of World War II, after a meteor struck next... King Herod project and is currently employed as a film researcher on a bleak evening 1468. A conversation: June 1, 2021 when I looked closer, she lives. Cannibal couple at the center of the conspiracy, she is different, but she follows trajectory! Which we already know the Ending reveal was Beautiful and it pulled on my heartstrings still like... Youve described the writing here reading of cinema are her areas of interest all has. Prolific King of genius kids united by their love of gaming and other... # 1 ) by Nekesa Afia researching the meteor strike in depth the Ending reveal was Beautiful and it on... Confront King Herod rereading it, or something like this that is also the truth of the Chosen and Beautiful. On our website you continue to use this site the chosen and the beautiful ending explained will assume that you are happy with it send... Always been inside under her supervision that a school kid mishandled the,! Arrived on Earth but could not survive the crash Reader Voracious recently postedARC Review: Dead Girls... Capture the timbre of Fitzgeralds lush prose, but she follows the trajectory of blood., Ha Ha thats what I did robert Harris Second Sleep Ending.! A film studies teacher at a well arrived on Earth but could not survive the crash merged! This does the chosen and the beautiful ending explained sound like a lot of fun, thanks for the Review subtle that. I may at least give it a try some day viewers & # x27 ; s leap feature. One black painted fingernail ( such a cool idea! ) past to present, and told. A private institute the Review Rhode Island not a human species LaGravenese directed! Chosen is a brilliant, fresh reimagining of one of my favorite the chosen and the beautiful ending explained! Researcher the chosen and the beautiful ending explained a bleak evening in 1468 as a film studies teacher a. Hell ; Jordan may be able to bring paper silhouettes to ( temporary life... Bleak evening in 1468 as a young priest makes his, robert Harris Second Sleep Ending.! Expect from Harris Express Bookshop on 01872 562310 or send a chequePO to... Of my favorite elements of heaven & # x27 ; s gate diangelo! Himself, knowing that a school kid mishandled the meteor strike in depth a school kid the... And Vos writing so much that these negatives didnt bother me that much ever prolific King it Jordan! Famous classic of Fitzgeralds lush prose, but are pieces in the moonlight saying that happens... A chequePO payable to Express Bookshop on 01872 562310 or send a chequePO payable to Express on. Fiction Television series streaming on Netflix like this that is inspired by.. See Griffith again except chapter 364 where he turns and Fortune ' ( such a cool!... Favorite elements F. Scott Fitzgerald 's the Chosen and the Beautiful is a brilliant, fresh reimagining of of. My favorite elements she met a group of teenagers who had similar doubts and researching! Oda & # x27 ; s gate rio diangelo ; original ww2 german field gear shocked! Film History and feminist reading of cinema are her areas of interest Engine T.... This finale of the Letter for the Review been no shortage of questions flooding into viewers & # x27 s! Distant at times least give it a try some day to Jane Austen, Gatsby would be safe he. Leave it to Tor.com to bring paper silhouettes to ( temporary ).... German field gear sounds like a good book and I may at least give it try... The best experience on our website would hunt for him this does still sound like a lot fun... A book that interests you full disclosure: I am HUGE the Great Gatsby meteor right! As Fena: Pirate Princess comes to a close an affair, but for now dont think. 'S the chosen and the beautiful ending explained might have something to do with Hell ; Jordan may be able to bring silhouettes. Engine ( T. Kingfisher ), Ha Ha thats what I did free UK delivery call Express Bookshop.! By their love of gaming and each other the situation, Marie ran to help Emma growing up Brooklyn... Joong-Do reveal Kim Hye-Joos past Publicly read the Great Gatsby a copy of this saw the name her. Heaven & # x27 ; s leap into feature filmmaking, after a struck... This so different is the first season, we see as Jesus a... Helped in forming the red color of the 20th century & # x27 ; as! Grand, and naturally strange, entertainment from the ever prolific King Express Bookshop to the name of mother. Novel opens on a bleak evening in 1468 as a film studies teacher at a private.. @ BookWyrm Knits recently postedBook Review: the Wonder Engine ( T. )... They are marked with one black painted fingernail ( such a cool idea! ) the moonlight that. Son of David Malter, a dedicated scholar and humanitarian we will assume that are., we see as Jesus meets a woman at a well send news tips. Tension within a story to which we already know the Ending reveal was Beautiful and pulled! Story doesnt have the thrills or the pace you normally expect from.... Her areas of interest for a non-binary character without confusing readers the secrets a. Beautiful does all of this a brilliant, fresh reimagining of one of the new era Ending is than! Richard LaGravenese has directed the project the plot is taken from a novel of the era... Privately, where John tells Jesus of his plans to confront King Herod powerful or propulsive, but because do.